Blog

Comparison of smart water analysers for swimming pools by "Piscine connectee"

In an article published in May 2024, Piscine Connectée compares several models of connected pool water analysers, including our ICO Pool. The author begins by outlining the purpose of a water analyser, followed by the different brands available on the market. Piscine Connectée then draws up comparisons based on product features and price ranges. Finally, Piscine Connectée also gives advice on other criteria that can help you decide between them.

Piscine Connectée blog page

Connected pool water analysers: what are they good for?

Piscine Connectée explains that a water analyser, or connected probe, makes it possible to have pH/Redox measurements and water temperature at your fingertips on your smartphone. ‘With the water analyser, water quality is measured and monitored every day. Thanks to notifications when water quality drops, you can act more quickly to considerably reduce the risk of having poor-quality water. The graphs show a history of measurements to give you a better understanding of how your pool's water quality is evolving.

Comparison of smart pool water analysers 

Piscine Connectée compares a total of 8 different brands of connected probes. Piscine connectée doesn't specify at the outset that there are models of water analysers that float in the water and others that are connected to pipes. Here's a quick summary:

  • Floating models
    • ICO Pool by Ondilo
    • Blue Connect Plus
    • FlipR start max
    • EcO by Iopool
    • Ofi Light by CCEI
  • Pipe-mounted models
    • Filtration +Analyse Oklyn
    • IntelliPool by Pentair

Piscine connectée presents all the products and lists the advantages and disadvantages of each.

Advantages and disadvantages of ICO Pool according to Piscine connectée

ICO Pool is described as one of the best connected probes on the market. Connected via Wi-Fi, ICO Pool can measure water quality, pH, redox and conductivity precisely for all types of pool (Chlorine / Bromine / Salt). Thanks to its intuitive application, users will be able to access all this data without any additional subscription.

BENEFITSDISADVANTAGES
Rechargeable battery
No subscription
Skill Amazon Alexa
Intuitive App
Complete measurements, including salt content
No Google Assistant skills

Comparison of smart water analysers by price range

For a more complete analysis, Piscine Connectée has chosen to classify the various competitors according to 3 different price ranges:

  • Products costing around €200, which only work via Bluetooth. So you need to be near your pool to take measurements. To make the measurements automatic and remote, some offer subscriptions or accessories.
  • Products costing around €400, which operate via Wi-Fi or Sigfox. Measurements are taken automatically, and measurements and notifications are displayed on the application.
  • Products costing over €1,000

ICO Pool is classified as a product costing around €400.

Which smart water analyser should you choose for your type of pool?

Piscine Connectée advises on the choice of a connected water analyser depending on the type of pool (salt pool, pool in a second home, above-ground pool).

For a salt pool 

ICO Pool is available in a Chlorine / Bromine version, but also in a Salt version. The conductivity sensor (grey) also analyses the salt level in your pool.

For an above-ground or Intex pool

ICO has been named the most comprehensive connected sensor of its competitors. Thanks to its features, ICO Pool can be used in both above-ground and in-ground pools.

What criteria should you use to choose your smart water analyser?

With the multitude of options available on the market, choosing a connected water analyser means taking a number of essential criteria into account: the cost and services included in the subscription, the reliability of the analyses provided, the quality of the connection to your network, the durability of the device, and its compatibility with your existing home automation systems.

Samrt analyser with no additional subscription

Piscine connectée points out that some water analysers only connect via Bluetooth, in the 200-euro price range, so measurements are not automatic. Wi-Fi-connected water analysers provide instant feedback. Some require subscriptions, others do not. ICO Pool works without a subscription. In fact, you will receive the analysis data directly on your application.

Durability of connected water analysers

Piscine connectée looked at the durability of water analysers, particularly the battery and the probes.

Cell or battery

Piscine connectée explains that some connected water analysers are battery-powered, others rechargeable. ICO Pool works with a rechargeable battery.

Connected water analyser probes

Piscine connectée informs us that the probes were developed using proprietary moulds. Only each brand markets replacement probes. For ICO Pool, the probes can be easily changed if necessary.

Which connected water analysers are compatible with Alexa, Google Assistant and API?

Certains analyseurs sont compatibles à Alexa et Google Assistant, avec ou sans abonnement. ICO Pool est uniquement compatible avec Amazon Alexa, mais sans abonnement supplémentaire.

To conclude

The Piscine Connectée article presents a detailed comparison of connected water analysers, highlighting the features and benefits of each model. ICO Pool stands out in particular for its Wi-Fi connectivity, its accurate measurements for all types of pools and its intuitive interface. Although there are some limitations, such as the lack of Google Assistant compatibility, ICO offers a complete solution that is suitable for the majority of users. This comparison helps pool owners choose the ideal device for their needs and budget.

Pour en savoir plus, n’hésitez pas à consulter l’article de Piscine Connectée : The best connected pool water analyser: the comparison!